Weeknight Plan

Occasions 路 Problem-solving guide

Is packing lunch cheaper than buying school lunch?

Quick answer

Add up what the packed foods you actually used cost, divide by the lunches, and set that against your school's price. In the school-lunch planner's worked example, 8 packed lunches use $17.46 of food. That's $2.18 a lunch against a $3.25 school lunch, or $8.54 a week less ($256.20 over 30 school weeks with the same menu). Swap the big bag of pretzels and the water bottles for snack packs and juice boxes and a packed lunch costs $2.82, so the gap drops to $3.48 a week. These are numbers only, not advice.

Source: no outside figures in this answer.

Updated October 23, 20266 min readPrintable checklist

  • $2.18a packed lunch in the worked example: $17.46 of food used across 8 lunches
  • $8.54a week less than 8 school lunches at $3.25
  • $24.23for the first store trip, more than the $17.46 used, because whole packages carry over
  • $2.82a lunch once the pretzels and drinks come in single packs

The cause

Why it happens

Packing can come out cheaper or dearer depending on which numbers you compare. Four things decide it.

1

Compare what you used, not the receipt

The example's store trip is $24.23, but it buys a 20-slice loaf when the week takes 8 slices. The other 12 are already paid for next week. The fair cost of this week's lunches is the $17.46 of food used.

2

Single packs cost more per ounce

At the sample prices, 1 oz of pretzels from a 16 oz bag at $2.99 costs about 19 cents. One pack from a 10-pack at $4.99 costs about 50 cents. Juice boxes add $3.49 a week where a bottle of water from home adds nothing. Together the week goes from $17.46 to $22.52.

3

Your school's price sets the line

The example box uses $2.18 of food, so a school price under about $2.18 makes the packed week the dearer one. At $2.25 the gap is 54 cents a week. Districts set their own prices, so type yours.

4

Some costs stay off the sheet

The pasta cooked extra at dinner counts in the dinner budget, not here, and containers, bags and ice packs aren't counted. So the packed figure reads a little low, and a close call can go either way.

Figure

One week, 8 lunches: buying at school against packing from home Packed bars count the food used this week, at the worked example's sample prices School lunch 8 脳 $3.25 $26.00 $3.25 a lunch Packed: bag and bottle 16 oz pretzel bag, water $17.46 $2.18 a lunch Packed: snack packs pretzel 10-pack, juice boxes $22.52 $2.82 a lunch store trip $24.23 store trip $29.72 Bread Turkey Apples Carrots Cheese sticks Pretzels, bag Pretzels, packs Juice boxes Against 8 school lunches: $8.54 a week less with the bag and bottle, $3.48 with snack packs Dashed line: the store trip, higher because whole packages carry into next week
The worked example week three ways: 8 school lunches, the packed week with pretzels from a bag and water from home, and the same week with pretzel snack packs and juice boxes. Each packed bar is split by food; the dashed line marks the store trip.

The fix

Step by step

  1. Count the packed lunches

    Each child times the days they pack, added up. In the example Ava packs 5 days and Sam 3, so the week has 8 packed lunches. Type the days in the school-lunch week planner.

  2. Price every food you buy for the box

    One line per food, with the package size and price from the shelf tag, in the unit you pack by: slices, ounces or pieces. A sandwich is two lines, the bread and the filling. Foods you already have stay unpriced.

  3. Read the used cost, not the store trip

    The example trip costs $24.23 and the week uses $17.46. What's left over (12 slices of bread, 8 oz of carrots, 4 cheese sticks and 11 oz of pretzels) belongs to next week.

  4. Type your school's lunch price

    Take the price from your district's menu page. The planner multiplies it by the packed lunches, $3.25 脳 8 = $26.00 in the example, and shows the gap: $8.54 a week. Type the school weeks left and it gives the stretch total, $256.20 over 30 weeks.

  5. Price the snack and drink two ways

    Add the snack twice, once from the big bag and once as single packs, and compare the used cost. In the example the pack version adds $5.06 a week with the juice boxes. The price per unit calculator does the same check at the shelf.

  6. Rerun it when prices change

    Fruit and deli prices move from week to week. Rerun the sheet with the new shelf tags before you trust last month's gap.

At a glance

The worked example's packed week

School price8 school lunchesPacked food usedDifference a weekOver 30 weeks
$2.25$18.00$17.46$0.54$16.20
$2.50$20.00$17.46$2.54$76.20
$2.75$22.00$17.46$4.54$136.20
$3.00$24.00$17.46$6.54$196.20
$3.25$26.00$17.46$8.54$256.20
$3.50$28.00$17.46$10.54$316.20
$3.25, snack packs and juice boxes$26.00$22.52$3.48$104.40

The worked example's packed week (8 lunches) against different school lunch prices, planned with the school-lunch week planner

From the kitchen table

Tips and tricks

  • Count the slices in a loaf once and write the number on the sheet. The label gives the weight, but you pack by the slice.

  • Price the drink. A bottle of water from home costs nothing on this sheet; in the example, juice boxes add $3.49 a week.

  • Mark dinner leftovers as "Extra from dinner". They do cost money, but it lands in the dinner budget, so the packed figure here reads a little low.

  • Check the school price each fall. A 25 cent change over 8 lunches a week and 30 weeks is $60.

  • When one child packs fewer days than the other, compare the cost per lunch, not the weekly total.

Let the tool do the arithmetic

School-lunch week planner

Tick the days each child packs and what goes in each box. Get the week sheet, a shopping list in whole packages, the cost per lunch and a packing countdown.

Open the school-lunch week plannerPrintable lunch week sheet

Figure

Two children, five school days, 8 packed lunches Ava packs every day. Sam buys at school on Wednesday and Friday. Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Ava Turkey sandwich + 5 more Pasta (dinner) + 5 more Turkey sandwich + 5 more Pasta (dinner) + 5 more Turkey sandwich + 5 more Sam Turkey sandwich + 4 more Pasta (dinner) + 4 more buys at school Pasta (dinner) + 4 more buys at school 2 boxes 2 boxes 1 box 2 boxes 1 box Needed this week (dark) and what whole packages buy (light) Sandwich bread 8 of 20 slices, 1 pack, 12 left Sliced turkey 8 of 9 oz, 1 pack, 1 left Apples 8 of 8, 1 pack Baby carrots 24 of 32 oz, 2 packs, 8 left Cheese sticks 8 of 12, 1 pack, 4 left Pretzels 5 of 16 oz, 1 pack, 11 left $24.23 store trip, whole packages $17.46 used: $2.18 a lunch $26.00 8 school lunches at $3.25 $8.54 a week less, $256.20 over 30 weeks
The worked example as the planner lays it out: who packs which day, what goes in each box, and the shopping list in whole packages.

Recommendation

What we'd do

Fill in one real week in the planner with the prices on your own shelf tags, read the used cost per lunch and set it against your district's price. If the gap is small, look at the snack and drink lines first; in the worked example they move the number most. Then decide day by day. Nothing says a child has to pack every day.

Numbers only, not advice

This page compares the prices you type. It doesn't say which lunch a child should eat or what your household should spend. You can also mix the two: pack most days and buy on the days the menu wins.

Packed or school lunch check

  • Packed days counted for each child
  • Every bought food priced in the unit you pack by
  • Used cost read, not the store trip
  • School price taken from the district menu page
  • Snack and drink lines priced both ways
  • Dinner extras left in the dinner budget
  • Sheet rerun when shelf prices change

Weeknight Plan 路 weeknightplan.com/occasions/guides/is-packing-lunch-cheaper/

Asked often

Questions

Is packing lunch cheaper than buying school lunch?

It depends on your school's price and what goes in the box. In the worked example, a packed lunch uses $2.18 of food against a $3.25 school lunch. With a school price under about $2.18, the same box costs more than buying.

How much does a packed school lunch cost?

Add up what each food costs for the amount used, then divide by the lunches. The worked example's box (a turkey sandwich or dinner pasta, an apple, carrots, a cheese stick and water) comes to $2.18 at sample prices. Your prices will differ, so type your own in the planner.

Why is my grocery receipt higher than the lunch cost?

Whole packages. The example's store trip is $24.23 but the week uses $17.46. The rest, 12 slices of bread, 8 oz of carrots, 4 cheese sticks and 11 oz of pretzels, is there for next week.

Do snack packs cost more than a big bag?

At the example's sample prices, yes. An ounce of pretzels from a 16 oz bag at $2.99 costs about 19 cents; one pack from a 10-pack at $4.99 costs about 50 cents. Check your own shelf tags with the price per unit calculator.

Does the comparison include containers and bags?

No. It counts only the foods you price. Containers, bags and ice packs aren't counted, and food cooked extra at dinner stays in the dinner budget.

Do the math

Tools for this

Keep reading

More guides

Checked and dated

Sources

This guide uses no outside figures. Every number on it is arithmetic you can check.

Numbers only, not nutrition, dietary, food-safety or financial advice. See every source on the sources page. Spotted an error? Tell us.

Photos: Arwen / Unsplash, Rens D / Unsplash, Ello / Unsplash and 12 more, see photo credits