Weeknight Plan

Grocery · Practical note

Same product, fair test: match sizes, brands and prices before you compare stores

Quick answer

Before you compare two stores, make sure each line is the same thing at both: same brand (or store brand at both), same cut or style, regular price rather than this week's sale, and priced by weight or volume, not by the package. In our sample, five items priced in a hurry made Store B look $21.81 a month cheaper. Priced fairly, the gap was $2.44, and two items switched stores.

Source: no outside figures in this answer.

Updated October 17, 20265 min readPrintable checklist

  • $21.81a month: how much cheaper Store B looked on the first pass
  • $2.44a month: the real gap once every line matched
  • 4 of 5items that needed fixing before the comparison was fair
  • 2 of 5items that switched to the other store after the fix: eggs and tomatoes

The cause

Why it happens

The arithmetic is the easy part. The mistakes happen at the shelf, when you write a price down.

1

Sale tags look like prices

A sale price is real for a week. If you'd stock up at the sale wherever you shop, compare regular prices. Otherwise one store gets credit for a discount it won't have next month.

2

Store brand vs name brand

A store brand next to a name brand compares two products, not two stores. Price the same brand at both, or the store brand at both if you'd buy either.

3

Cuts and styles hide in the name

"Chicken thighs" can be bone-in or boneless, "tomatoes" can be whole or diced. The cheaper line is often a different product with the same word on the tag.

4

Cans aren't a unit

A 28 oz can and a 14.5 oz can are both "a can". Count them as cans and the small can always wins. Price by the ounce, the way the shelf tag's unit price does.

Figure

Same five items, two stores, priced twice A month of what two adults use, sample prices. Bars to scale. First pass $69.42 Store A $47.61 Store B B looks $21.81 cheaper Fair test $71.42 Store A $68.98 Store B B is $2.44 cheaper What changed Eggs regular price, not this week's sale Coffee same brand at both Chicken boneless at both Tomatoes by the ounce, not the can Cheese already fair: size is fine
Five items, two stores, priced twice. The first pass mixed a sale price, two brands, two cuts and two can sizes. The fair test matched every line.

The fix

Step by step

  1. Write the item, not the word

    "Eggs, large, dozen", "boneless chicken thighs", "diced tomatoes, 28 oz". Use what you'd actually put in the cart, so you can look for exactly that at the second store.

  2. Copy the regular price

    If the tag shows a sale, write the regular price too. In the sample, Store A's eggs were $2.49 a dozen on sale and $3.49 regular. At regular price, Store A's 24 eggs cost $6.98 a month against $5.98 at Store B: the eggs switch sides.

  3. Match the brand

    Store B's $6.99 coffee was the store brand; Store A's $9.99 was a name brand. The same name brand at Store B was $9.49. For 24 oz a month that's $19.98 against $18.98, not $19.98 against $13.98.

  4. Match the cut

    Store B's $1.79 chicken thighs were bone-in; Store A's $3.49 were boneless. Store B's boneless thighs were $3.29 a pound. For 6 lb a month: $20.94 at A, $19.74 at B, a $1.20 gap rather than $10.20.

  5. Price by weight or volume

    Store A sold 28 oz cans at $1.69, Store B 14.5 oz cans at $0.99. Eight big cans a month is 224 oz: $13.52 at A, and $15.29 at B, which takes 16 small cans. Counted as cans, B looked $5.60 cheaper. By the ounce, A is $1.77 cheaper. The price per unit calculator does this from the two shelf tags.

  6. Run the worksheet once every line matches

    Enter the matched items in the store comparison worksheet. The sample comes to $71.42 a month at Store A and $68.98 at Store B: $2.44 apart, close enough that the extra trip may decide it.

At a glance

Sample prices: a month of five items at two stores, first pass vs fair test

ItemUsed a monthFirst pass AFirst pass BFair AFair BWhat changed
Eggs24$4.98$5.98$6.98$5.98A's regular price, not the sale
Ground coffee24 oz$19.98$13.98$19.98$18.98Same brand at B
Chicken thighs6 lb$20.94$10.74$20.94$19.74Boneless at B
Shredded cheese2 lb$10.00$8.99$10.00$8.99Already fair
Canned tomatoes224 oz$13.52$7.92$13.52$15.29By the ounce, not the can
Month total$69.42$47.61$71.42$68.98Gap $21.81 → $2.44

Sample prices: a month of five items at two stores, first pass vs fair test

From the kitchen table

Tips and tricks

  • Take a photo of each shelf tag with the product in the frame. The size and the exact name are on the tag, and you won't have to remember which can it was.

  • Mark sale prices with an S on your sheet. You can still use them, but only when you'd buy enough at the sale to last until the next one.

  • If one store doesn't carry your brand, leave that cell empty. The worksheet compares only the items priced at every store and lists the rest apart.

  • Watch for shrinking packages. A bag that went from 12 oz to 10 oz at the same price is a 20 percent price rise, and only the unit price shows it.

Let the tool do the arithmetic

Store comparison worksheet

Price your monthly staples at up to three stores and see the cheapest store, the cheapest way to split the list, and whether a club fee pays off.

Open the store comparison worksheetPrintable store comparison worksheet

Figure

Eight monthly staples, every way to split the list Bar = cost of what you use in a month, colored by store. Hatched end = the club fee share ($60 ÷ 12 = $5.00). $0 $15 $30 $45 $60 $75 Discount + Super2 stops $54.18 cheapest Discount + Super + Club3 stops $54.37 +$0.19 Super + Club2 stops $55.90 +$1.72 Discount + Club2 stops $56.17 +$1.99 Discount1 stop $57.18 +$3.00 Club1 stop $57.70 +$3.52 Super1 stop $71.48 +$17.30 Discount grocerSupermarketWarehouse clubClub fee
The store comparison worksheet's own example: once every line matches, the worksheet ranks every way to split the list.

Recommendation

What we'd do

Price ten items you buy every month, matched line by line, on one ordinary week at each store. If the fair gap is only a few dollars, let the trip, the hours and the parking decide. If it's large, run the store comparison worksheet with your real monthly amounts before you change where you shop. Numbers only, not advice.

Numbers only, not advice

These are sample prices for a worked example, not prices at any real store. This page doesn't name chains or say where to shop. It only checks that the comparison compares the same things.

Fair test: before you compare stores

  • Each item written as you'd buy it: brand, style, cut and size
  • Regular price copied next to any sale price
  • Same brand at both stores, or store brand at both
  • Same cut and style at both (bone-in or boneless, whole or diced)
  • Price per ounce, pound or fluid ounce, never per package
  • Weight compared with weight and volume with volume
  • Monthly amount you use written for each item
  • Items missing at one store left blank, not swapped
  • Prices dated, so you can re-check in a few months

Weeknight Plan · weeknightplan.com/grocery/guides/same-product-fair-test/

Asked often

Questions

How do I compare grocery prices between stores fairly?

Match each item first: same brand, same cut or style, regular price, and priced per ounce or pound rather than per package. Then add up a month of what you use at each store. In our sample, matching every line shrank a $21.81 gap to $2.44.

Should I compare store brands or name brands?

Whichever you'd actually buy, as long as both stores get the same kind. Store brand against name brand compares two products, not two stores.

Do sale prices count?

Only if you'd buy at the sale price every month. A one-week sale makes a store look cheaper for that week only. Use the regular price for the comparison and note the sale apart.

What if the sizes are different?

That's fine. Compare the price per ounce or per pound, which the price per unit calculator works out. Different sizes only become a problem when you count packages.

Can I compare a jar sold by weight with a bottle sold by volume?

Not directly. Ounces of weight and fluid ounces of volume are different units, so the worksheet asks you to price both the same way. Find the same product sold the same way at both stores.

Do the math

Tools for this

Keep reading

More guides

Checked and dated

Sources

This guide uses no outside figures. Every number on it is arithmetic you can check.

Numbers only, not nutrition, dietary, food-safety or financial advice. See every source on the sources page. Spotted an error? Tell us.

Photos: Arwen / Unsplash, Rens D / Unsplash, Ello / Unsplash and 12 more, see photo credits