Weeknight Plan

Grocery · Problem-solving guide

Is the warehouse club membership paying for itself? A fee check from your own receipts

Quick answer

Take one month of club receipts. For each item, work out what the amount you actually use would cost at the club and at the store you'd otherwise go to. Add up the difference and multiply by 12. If that beats the yearly fee, the card pays for itself. In our example, a family's eight club staples save $502.20 a year against the supermarket but only $75.00 against their discount grocer, $10.00 more than a $65 fee. Buy just the four items the club wins and the saving goes up to $115.08.

Source: no outside figures in this answer.

Updated October 16, 20266 min readPrintable checklist

A 25 lb bag of rice, a coffee canister, bags of broccoli and shredded cheese, a gallon of milk and a carton of eggs on a counter, with a printed price list, a receipt and a pencil in front
  • $75.00a year saved at the club against the discount grocer, for all eight items
  • $502.20a year saved against the supermarket, for the same list and the same prices
  • $5.42a month: the $65 fee ÷ 12, what the club has to save just to break even
  • $115.08a year saved when only the four items the club wins come from the club

The cause

Why it happens

The fee check itself is one line of arithmetic. Most checks go wrong earlier, when the wrong numbers go into it.

1

The wrong store to compare

Club prices look great next to a full-price supermarket. If you'd otherwise shop at a discount grocer, that's the comparison that counts. In the example the same list saves $41.85 a month against one and $6.25 against the other.

2

The bag, not the month

A 25 lb sack of rice costs $18.99 at the register, but this family uses 8 lb a month. The saving only counts on the 8 lb, and only if the rest of the bag gets used.

3

Losers hide in the cart

Clubs don't win on every item. In the example the club charges more for eggs, milk, chicken and bananas than the discount grocer does. A check that only adds up the wins makes the card look better than it is.

4

The fee lands once

One renewal charge a year is easy to forget by March. Spread it as fee ÷ 12 and set it against each month's saving, and the check gets simple: the card pays when the monthly saving beats the monthly share.

Figure

Warehouse club against the discount grocer, item by item What each item costs a month for what the household uses. Right = cheaper at the club. −$2 −$1 $0 $1 $2 $3 $4 $5 ◀ club costs more club costs less ▶ Long-grain rice +$3.88 Ground coffee +$4.48 Frozen broccoli +$0.68 Shredded cheese +$0.55 Bananas −$0.05 Milk −$0.62 Eggs −$1.07 Chicken breasts −$1.60 All eight at the club: $9.59 − $3.34 = $6.25 a month, $75.00 a year. Fee $65: $10.00 to spare. Only the four teal items at the club: $9.59 a month, $115.08 a year. Fee $65: $50.08 to spare. Against the supermarket instead: $41.85 a month, $502.20 a year. Fee $65: $437.20 to spare. The fee check only means something against the store you would really use. Sample prices; a month = what the household goes through, not the package size.
The example family's eight staples, club against discount grocer, as a month's cost of what they use. Four items are cheaper at the club, four are cheaper at the grocer. The box below runs the fee check three ways.

The fix

Step by step

  1. Pull one month of club receipts

    Use a normal month, not the one with a holiday stock-up or a new TV. Circle the food items you buy every month. Skip the things you only bought because you were standing in front of them.

  2. Write down what you use in a month

    Not the package size. The family in the example goes through 36 eggs, 4 gallons of milk, 8 lb of chicken breasts, 8 lb of rice, 3 lb of shredded cheese, 36 oz of coffee, 6 lb of frozen broccoli and 8 lb of bananas.

  3. Price the same items at the store you'd use instead

    Same size of egg, same kind of rice, same style of cheese. Copy the shelf price and the package size, then turn both stores' tags into a price per unit with the price per unit calculator.

  4. Work out a month's cost of what you use

    Price per unit × the month's amount, at each store. For rice: $18.99 ÷ 25 lb × 8 lb = $6.08 at the club against $2.49 ÷ 2 lb × 8 lb = $9.96 at the grocer, so the club saves $3.88. For eggs: $6.49 ÷ 24 × 36 = $9.74 against $2.89 ÷ 12 × 36 = $8.67, so the club costs $1.07 more.

  5. Add it up and check the fee

    The family's eight items cost $95.11 at the club and $101.36 at the discount grocer: $6.25 a month, or $75.00 a year. Take away the $65 fee and $10.00 is left. That's a pass, just barely, and it'd take 11 months of shopping to earn the fee back.

  6. Try the club for its winners only

    Buy the rice, coffee, frozen broccoli and cheese at the club, and the rest at the grocer. The saving becomes $9.59 a month, or $115.08 a year, which leaves $50.08 after the fee. The store comparison worksheet tries every split like this and ranks them.

At a glance

The example: a month of eight staples at three stores

ItemUsed a monthDiscount grocerSupermarketWarehouse club
Eggs36$8.67$11.97$9.74
Milk4 gal$11.96$15.16$12.58
Chicken breasts8 lb$22.32$27.92$23.92
Long-grain rice8 lb$9.96$13.16$6.08
Shredded cheese3 lb$13.14$17.94$12.59
Ground coffee36 oz$19.47$26.97$14.99
Frozen broccoli6 lb$11.92$18.32$11.24
Bananas8 lb$3.92$5.52$3.97
Month total$101.36$136.96$95.11 + $5.42 fee

The example: a month of eight staples at three stores (sample prices, $65 club fee)

Let the tool do the arithmetic

Store comparison worksheet

Price your monthly staples at up to three stores and see the cheapest store, the cheapest way to split the list, and whether a club fee pays off.

Open the store comparison worksheetPrintable store comparison worksheet

Figure

Eight monthly staples, every way to split the list Bar = cost of what you use in a month, colored by store. Hatched end = the club fee share ($60 ÷ 12 = $5.00). $0 $15 $30 $45 $60 $75 Discount + Super2 stops $54.18 cheapest Discount + Super + Club3 stops $54.37 +$0.19 Super + Club2 stops $55.90 +$1.72 Discount + Club2 stops $56.17 +$1.99 Discount1 stop $57.18 +$3.00 Club1 stop $57.70 +$3.52 Super1 stop $71.48 +$17.30 Discount grocerSupermarketWarehouse clubClub fee
The store comparison worksheet runs the same check on its own example: a club that wins most items and still loses once its fee share is counted.

Numbers only, not advice

This page does arithmetic on prices and a fee you type in. It doesn't say which store or membership to pick, and it leaves out card rewards, gas and the extra trip. If the check comes out close, weigh those yourself. A $10 margin can disappear with one wasted bag of something.

The club fee check

  • One ordinary month of club receipts, with the one-off buys crossed out
  • Monthly amount you use written next to each food item
  • Same items priced at the store you'd use instead, same sizes and styles
  • Price per unit × monthly amount worked out at both stores
  • Items the club loses kept in the count, not just the wins
  • Monthly saving × 12 set against the yearly fee
  • A second run with only the club's winners bought there
  • Date written on the sheet so you can redo it before the renewal

Weeknight Plan · weeknightplan.com/grocery/guides/is-the-club-membership-worth-it/

Asked often

Questions

Is a warehouse club membership worth it for a small household?

It depends on what you use, not on household size alone. Two people who go through a lot of coffee, rice or frozen vegetables can clear a fee easily; a household that buys mostly fresh food in small amounts may not. Run the check on your own month: saving × 12 against the fee.

Which store should I compare the club with?

The one you'd actually shop at if you dropped the card. In the example the club looks like a big winner against the supermarket ($502.20 a year) and only just pays against the discount grocer ($75.00 a year, with a $65 fee).

Do I count the whole bulk package or only what I use?

Only what you use in a month. A big package costs more cash on the day and leaves stock for next month. If some of it goes unused, the price per unit you really paid goes up, and the saving goes down with it.

What if I share the membership with someone?

Use your share of the fee. If two households split a $65 card, each runs the check against $32.50 a year, or about $2.71 a month.

How often should I redo the check?

Once before each renewal is enough for most people, and again if your usual store changes or your list changes a lot. Shelf prices move, so copy fresh tags each time.

Do the math

Tools for this

Keep reading

More guides

Checked and dated

Sources

This guide uses no outside figures. Every number on it is arithmetic you can check.

Numbers only, not nutrition, dietary, food-safety or financial advice. See every source on the sources page. Spotted an error? Tell us.

Photos: Arwen / Unsplash, Rens D / Unsplash, Ello / Unsplash and 12 more, see photo credits