Weeknight Plan

Grocery · Know-how

One grocery store or two: how to tell when a second stop is worth it

Quick answer

Find what the split saves in a month: buy each item where its price per unit is lowest, and compare that total with your cheapest single store. Then divide the saving by the extra stops, minutes and miles it takes. In our example a family saves $7.80 a month by getting chicken, beef and salad at the supermarket. As a weekly detour that's $1.95 a stop and $7.80 an hour of extra time. If the supermarket is on the way home, it's $11.70 an hour with no extra driving. Whether that's worth it depends on what your time and driving are worth to you.

Source: no outside figures in this answer.

Updated October 16, 20265 min readPrintable checklist

Two grocery bags in a car trunk, a paper bag with apples, spaghetti and canned tomatoes and a canvas tote with a salad kit and chicken thighs, with a handwritten list lying across them
  • $7.80a month saved by splitting nine staples between two stores
  • 3 of 9items cheaper at the second store; the whole saving comes from those three
  • $1.95saved per stop with four second stops a month
  • $93.60a year from the split, for 48 stops at the second store

The cause

Why it happens

Shoppers who split the list tend to remember the big price gaps and forget the trips. The saving is real, but it's smaller than the gaps make it look, and it gets divided by every extra stop.

1

Only the winners count

The split saves money only on items the second store sells for less, and only by the gap. Canned tomatoes that cost 59% more at the supermarket don't matter if you keep buying them at the grocer.

2

Percentages flatter small items

A 34% gap on chicken thighs is $3.00 a month for 6 lb. A big percentage on a cheap item you buy once a month can be worth a few cents.

3

The trip comes every time

One store a week means four trips a month. Two stores means eight stops, and the extra four each cost parking, a checkout line and maybe a detour.

4

On-the-way stops are different

A store you already drive past costs a few minutes and no extra miles. The same saving is worth more when the trip is nearly free.

Figure

What the second stop saves, and what it costs in trips Nine monthly staples. Discount grocer for six, supermarket for three. Saved a month Chicken thighs $3.00 Ground beef $2.80 Bagged salad $2.00 = $7.80 $0 $2 $4 $6 $8 Discount grocer alone: $96.04 a month. Split: $50.18 + $38.06 = $88.24. A. Weekly detour 4 extra stops a month 15 minutes and 6 miles each = 60 minutes, 24 miles $1.95 a stop about 33¢ a mile $7.80 an hour B. On the way home 4 stops a month, no extra miles 10 minutes each to park and pay = 40 minutes, 0 miles $1.95 a stop no extra miles $11.70 an hour A year: $7.80 × 12 = $93.60, for 48 stops at the second store. Compare the per-stop, per-mile and per-hour figures with what your own time and driving are worth.
The example split, to scale: $7.80 a month from three items, then divided by the trips it takes. The weekly detour and the on-the-way stop save the same dollars but cost different minutes and miles.

The fix

Step by step

  1. Price your monthly list at both stores

    Write down what you go through in a month and copy both stores' shelf prices and package sizes. The family in the example has nine staples: eggs, milk, chicken thighs, ground beef, pasta, canned tomatoes, apples, bagged salad and cereal.

  2. Find the cheapest single store

    Cost of what you use = price per unit × the month's amount, added up. The discount grocer comes to $96.04 and the supermarket to $108.39, so the grocer is the one-store answer.

  3. Split the list item by item

    Give each item to the store with the lower price per unit. Here the supermarket wins chicken thighs ($1.49 against $1.99 a pound), ground beef and bagged salad. The split total is $50.18 + $38.06 = $88.24, so it saves $7.80 a month.

  4. Count the extra stops, minutes and miles

    Use your own numbers. The family shops weekly, so the split adds 4 stops a month. As a detour, each one takes 15 minutes and 6 miles round trip: 60 minutes and 24 miles a month.

  5. Divide the saving by the trip

    $7.80 ÷ 4 stops = $1.95 a stop. $7.80 ÷ 24 miles = about 33 cents a mile. $7.80 ÷ 60 minutes × 60 = $7.80 an hour. If the supermarket is on the way home and a stop takes 10 minutes, it's $7.80 for 40 minutes, or $11.70 an hour, with no extra miles.

  6. Decide, then write the list by store

    Compare those figures with what your time and driving are worth to you. If the split stays, write the list in two parts on the pantry-first grocery list so nothing gets bought twice. The store comparison worksheet prints the list by store for you.

At a glance

The example: a month of nine staples at two stores

ItemUsed a monthDiscount grocerSupermarketSplit buys at
Eggs30$7.23$9.98Discount grocer
Milk3 gal$8.97$11.37Discount grocer
Chicken thighs6 lb$11.94$8.94Supermarket, saves $3.00
Ground beef4 lb$19.96$17.16Supermarket, saves $2.80
Dry pasta4 lb$4.76$5.96Discount grocer
Canned tomatoes8 cans$9.52$15.12Discount grocer
Apples6 lb$7.74$10.74Discount grocer
Bagged salad4 bags$13.96$11.96Supermarket, saves $2.00
Cereal72 oz$11.96$17.16Discount grocer
Month total$96.04$108.39Split $88.24

The example: a month of nine staples at two stores (sample prices)

Let the tool do the arithmetic

Store comparison worksheet

Price your monthly staples at up to three stores and see the cheapest store, the cheapest way to split the list, and whether a club fee pays off.

Open the store comparison worksheetPrintable store comparison worksheet

Figure

Eight monthly staples, every way to split the list Bar = cost of what you use in a month, colored by store. Hatched end = the club fee share ($60 ÷ 12 = $5.00). $0 $15 $30 $45 $60 $75 Discount + Super2 stops $54.18 cheapest Discount + Super + Club3 stops $54.37 +$0.19 Super + Club2 stops $55.90 +$1.72 Discount + Club2 stops $56.17 +$1.99 Discount1 stop $57.18 +$3.00 Club1 stop $57.70 +$3.52 Super1 stop $71.48 +$17.30 Discount grocerSupermarketWarehouse clubClub fee
With three stores there are seven ways to shop. The store comparison worksheet ranks all of them for its own example and marks how many stops each one takes.

Numbers only, not advice

This page divides a saving by trips. It doesn't put a price on your time or your car, and it doesn't pick a store for you. Gas, parking and the chance of extra impulse buys at a second store aren't in the math; weigh them yourself.

The second-stop check

  • Monthly list with the amount you use of each item
  • Shelf price and package size copied at both stores
  • Cheapest single store found from the month totals
  • Split total worked out, with each item at its cheaper store
  • Extra stops, minutes and miles a month counted from your own trips
  • Saving ÷ stops, ÷ miles and per hour written down
  • On-the-way option checked before ruling a second store out
  • List rewritten by store if the split stays

Weeknight Plan · weeknightplan.com/grocery/guides/one-store-or-two/

Asked often

Questions

Is it worth shopping at two grocery stores?

Only you can price your time and driving, but the arithmetic is quick: monthly split saving ÷ extra stops, miles and hours. In the example that's $1.95 a stop. Some people would drive across town for that; others wouldn't cross the parking lot.

How much should a second store save to be worth the trip?

There's no single figure. Put your own cost per mile and what an hour is worth to you next to the per-mile and per-hour figures. If the store is on a route you already drive, the miles drop out and only the minutes are left.

Why does the split save so little when some prices are much lower?

Because most items already sit at the cheaper store. The split only gains on the items the second store wins, and only by the gap. In the example those are three of nine items, worth $3.00, $2.80 and $2.00 a month.

Can I go to the second store every other week instead?

For items you can buy two weeks at a time, yes, and that halves the stops. Run the numbers with the new stop count. For fresh food, check how long it keeps in USDA FoodKeeper before you change the plan. We don't give storage times here.

Do the math

Tools for this

Keep reading

More guides

Checked and dated

Sources

This guide uses no outside figures. Every number on it is arithmetic you can check.

Numbers only, not nutrition, dietary, food-safety or financial advice. See every source on the sources page. Spotted an error? Tell us.

Photos: Arwen / Unsplash, Rens D / Unsplash, Ello / Unsplash and 12 more, see photo credits