Weeknight Plan

Grocery · Tool and printable

Store comparison worksheet

Quick answer

Price the same items at each store, turn every shelf price into a price per unit, then multiply by how much you use in a month. In the worked example the discount grocer is the cheapest single store at $57.18 for eight staples. Buying the chicken at the supermarket brings it to $54.18. The warehouse club saves $4.48 a month on this list, which doesn't cover its $5.00 monthly share of a $60 fee.

Source: no outside figures. This tool works only from what you enter.

Updated October 15, 2026Sources checked October 10, 2026Printable store comparison worksheet

Three paper grocery bags on a kitchen counter with a milk jug, eggs, bananas, two cans, a measuring cup, and a blank three-column sheet with a pencil

Try it

Filled in with the worked example below. Change any number and the result updates.

The stores

Leave the membership fee empty for a store that doesn't charge one. A warehouse club's fee is on your card or receipt.

The items you buy every month
Discount grocer
Supermarket
Warehouse club
Discount grocer
Supermarket
Warehouse club
Discount grocer
Supermarket
Warehouse club
Discount grocer
Supermarket
Warehouse club
Discount grocer
Supermarket
Warehouse club
Discount grocer
Supermarket
Warehouse club
Discount grocer
Supermarket
Warehouse club
Discount grocer
Supermarket
Warehouse club
Discount grocer
Supermarket
Warehouse club
Discount grocer
Supermarket
Warehouse club

"Used a month" is how much your household goes through, like 24 eggs or 5 lb of rice. Copy each store's shelf price and the package size printed on the label. For meat or produce sold by the pound, enter the price per pound with a size of 1 lb. Leave a store's cells empty if it doesn't carry the item. Empty rows are ignored.

Cheapest way to buy these 8 items Discount grocer and Supermarket: $54.18 a month

Best single storeDiscount grocer at $57.18. Splitting the list across 2 stores saves $3.00 a month for 1 extra stop.

Everything at Discount grocer
$57.18
Everything at Warehouse club (with $5.00 a month of the fee)
$57.70 +$0.52
Everything at Supermarket
$71.48 +$14.30

Item by item

ItemDiscount grocerSupermarketWarehouse club
Eggs
24 count a month
$0.24 / count
$5.78lowest
$0.33 / count
$7.98+38.1%
$0.27 / count
$6.49+12.3%
Milk
2 gallon a month
$2.99 / gallon
$5.98lowest
$3.79 / gallon
$7.58+26.8%
$3.15 / gallon
$6.29+5.2%
Long-grain rice
5 lb a month
$1.25 / lb
$6.23+63.9%
$1.65 / lb
$8.23+116.6%
$0.76 / lb
$3.80lowest
Chicken thighs
6 lb a month
$1.99 / lb
$11.94+33.6%
$1.49 / lb
$8.94lowest
$1.79 / lb
$10.74+20.1%
Canned tomatoes
8 count a month
$1.19 / count
$9.52lowest
$1.89 / count
$15.12+58.8%
$1.25 / count
$9.99+4.9%
Shredded cheese
2 lb a month
$4.38 / lb
$8.76+4.4%
$5.98 / lb
$11.96+42.5%
$4.20 / lb
$8.39lowest
Bananas
6 lb a month
$0.49 / lb
$2.94lowest
$0.69 / lb
$4.14+40.8%
$0.50 / lb
$2.98+1.4%
Olive oil
17 fl oz a month
$0.35 / fl oz
$6.03+49.9%
$0.44 / fl oz
$7.53+87.4%
$0.24 / fl oz
$4.02lowest
Ground coffee
24 oz a month
no price$0.75 / oz
$17.98+79.9%
$0.42 / oz
$9.99lowest

Each cell shows the price per unit, then the cost of what you use in a month (price per unit × amount). A big package lasts more than a month, so this is the fair monthly figure, not the cash at the register.

Not in the totals, because a store has no price for it: Ground coffee (missing at Discount grocer; lowest so far Warehouse club, $9.99 a month).

Every way to split the list

Shop atStopsItemsFee shareMonthVs cheapest
Discount grocer and Supermarket2$54.18-$54.18cheapest
Discount grocer, Supermarket and Warehouse club3$49.37$5.00$54.37+$0.19
Supermarket and Warehouse club2$50.90$5.00$55.90+$1.72
Discount grocer and Warehouse club2$51.17$5.00$56.17+$1.99
Discount grocer1$57.18-$57.18+$3.00
Warehouse club1$52.70$5.00$57.70+$3.52
Supermarket1$71.48-$71.48+$17.30

Warehouse club fee check. On these items it saves $4.48 a month against Discount grocer, so $53.76 a year against a $60.00 fee: $6.24 short. It takes about 14 months of this basket to earn the fee back. Only the items on this list count, so add the other things you'd buy there before you decide.

Shopping list for the cheapest plan

  • Discount grocer$52.43 at the register
    • Eggs: 2 × 12 count at $2.89
    • Milk: 2 × 1 gallon at $2.99
    • Long-grain rice: 3 × 2 lb at $2.49 (1 lb left for next month)
    • Canned tomatoes: 8 × 1 count at $1.19
    • Shredded cheese: 4 × 8 oz at $2.19
    • Bananas: 6 × 1 lb at $0.49
    • Olive oil: 2 × 16.9 fl oz at $5.99 (16.8 fl oz left for next month)
  • Supermarket$8.94 at the register
    • Chicken thighs: 6 × 1 lb at $1.49

Step by step, no jargon

How to use this, in plain words

  1. 1

    List the things you buy every month, and how much of each you go through, like 24 eggs, 2 gallons of milk or 5 lb of rice. Your last few receipts are the quickest way to find them.

  2. 2

    At each store, copy the shelf price and the package size printed on the label. For meat and produce sold by the pound, type the price per pound and a size of 1 lb.

  3. 3

    Add the yearly membership fee for any store that charges one. It's printed on the card or the renewal receipt.

  4. 4

    Read the cheapest split at the top, then the item table to see which store wins each item and by how much.

  5. 5

    Print the comparison. The shopping list at the bottom says what to buy where and how much cash each stop takes this month.

Before you start

  • Compare the same thing at every store: same kind of rice, same egg size, same cheese. A store brand against a name brand is a different test.
  • Use regular shelf prices, not this week's sale, unless the sale price comes back often. One sale can make a store look cheaper than it is.
  • Put in what you really use in a month, not what the big package holds. A bulk bag only saves money if you finish it.
  • A second stop costs time and gas. If the split saves only a dollar or two a month, one store is probably the better plan.

The method

How it works

  1. Price per unit = shelf price ÷ package size, with the size turned into the unit you count the item in (16 oz to a pound, 128 fl oz to a gallon).
  2. Cost of what you use = price per unit × the amount you go through in a month. A 25 lb bag of rice counts only for the 5 lb you use this month.
  3. Store total = the cost of what you use, added up over the items every store prices, plus a month's share of any membership fee (yearly fee ÷ 12).
  4. Split plan = each item at the store in the plan with the lowest price per unit. The tool tries every combination of stores and ranks them by month total. A fee only counts when the plan buys something at that store.
  5. Fee check = (cheapest other store's total − this store's items) × 12, against the yearly fee.
  6. At the register = packages you need to cover the month (rounded up) × shelf price. Big packages cost more cash today and leave stock for next month.

Source: NIST Handbook 44 (2026), Appendix C, checked October 10, 2026.

Step by step

Worked example

Two adults price eight things they buy every month, plus coffee, at three stores near them. The prices are one week of shelf tags: eggs, milk, rice, chicken thighs, canned tomatoes, shredded cheese, bananas and olive oil. The warehouse club charges $60 a year. The discount grocer doesn't sell their coffee, so that cell stays empty. These are sample prices; yours will differ.

  1. Price per unit = shelf price ÷ package size. Eggs: $2.89 ÷ 12 = $0.24 each at Discount grocer, $6.49 ÷ 24 = $0.27 at Warehouse club.
  2. Cost of what you use = price per unit × the month's amount. Rice, 5 lb a month: $6.23 at Discount grocer, $3.80 at Warehouse club. The club's 25 lb bag still costs $18.99 at the register and lasts 5 months.
  3. Add the 8 items that have a price everywhere: Discount grocer $57.18, Warehouse club $52.70, Supermarket $71.48. The club's $60.00 yearly fee adds $60.00 ÷ 12 = $5.00 a month, so its total is $57.70.
  4. Best single store: Discount grocer, $57.18. Best split: Discount grocer and Supermarket, $54.18, which is $3.00 less. Adding the club as a third stop comes to $54.37, because the fee share is more than the club saves on this list.
  5. Fee check: the club saves $4.48 a month against Discount grocer, so $53.76 a year, $6.24 short of the $60.00 fee. Coffee isn't in the totals, since Discount grocer has no price for it.

Figure

Eight monthly staples, every way to split the list Bar = cost of what you use in a month, colored by store. Hatched end = the club fee share ($60 ÷ 12 = $5.00). $0 $15 $30 $45 $60 $75 Discount + Super2 stops $54.18 cheapest Discount + Super + Club3 stops $54.37 +$0.19 Super + Club2 stops $55.90 +$1.72 Discount + Club2 stops $56.17 +$1.99 Discount1 stop $57.18 +$3.00 Club1 stop $57.70 +$3.52 Super1 stop $71.48 +$17.30 Discount grocerSupermarketWarehouse clubClub fee
Every way to split the worked example's list, to scale. The two-store plan without the club is cheapest, because the club's fee share is larger than what it saves on these eight items.

Put it on the fridge

What to record

Print the comparison above with your prices filled in, or print a blank sheet to take to the stores. One row for each item:

  • Item
  • Used a month
  • Store 1 price and size
  • Store 2 price and size
  • Store 3 price and size
  • Lowest price per unit
  • Buy it at

Open the printable store comparison worksheet

A hand holding a pencil over a folded sheet below a shelf of rice, with a small bag of rice next to a large one

Your household

Variants

1

Two stores only

Leave the third store empty. The tool compares the two and shows whether splitting the list between them saves anything.

2

Club fee shared with family

If two households split one membership, type your share of the yearly fee. The fee check then uses only what you pay.

3

Online order against the store

Use the delivery or pickup prices as one store and add any yearly delivery membership as its fee. Per-order delivery charges aren't in the math, so add them to the item prices if you pay one every time.

4

Check one aisle at a time

Start with the ten things you buy most. Those are the items where a price gap adds up fastest, and you can add more rows next month.

Published figures

Numbers this tool uses

FigureValueSource, date checked
1 pound16 ounces = 453.59237 gNIST Handbook 44 (2026), Appendix C, October 10, 2026
Pint, quart, gallon16, 32 and 128 US fluid ouncesNIST Handbook 44 (2026), Appendix C, October 10, 2026
1 US fluid ounce29.57353 mLNIST Handbook 44 (2026), Appendix C, October 10, 2026

Limitations

  • Planning estimate; check the shelf tags again every few months, since prices and sizes change.
  • Gas, time and delivery charges for an extra stop aren't in the totals. Weigh them yourself against the split saving.
  • Numbers only, not advice. The tool compares the prices you type and doesn't say which store or membership to choose.

Checking the result

If the answer surprises you

The warehouse club wins most items but still loses? Its fee share counts against every month. On a short list the per-unit savings can be smaller than the fee.

The register total is far above the monthly figure? Bulk packages cost more cash on the day. The monthly figure spreads that cost over the months the package lasts.

An item is missing from the totals? It needs a price at every store to count in the comparison. It still shows in the item table with its cheapest store so far.

Asked often

Questions

Is a warehouse club membership worth it?

It depends on what you'd buy there. Add up what the items you'd buy there cost at the club and at your usual store, multiply the monthly difference by 12, and compare it with the yearly fee. In the worked example the club saves $53.76 a year on eight staples, which is $6.24 short of a $60 fee.

Is it cheaper to shop at two grocery stores?

Sometimes. The tool tries every way to split your list and ranks them. If the cheapest split saves only a little over one store, the extra stop may cost more in time and gas than it saves.

How do I compare a 25 lb bag with a 2 lb bag?

Divide each price by its size to get the price per pound, then multiply by what you use in a month. The tool also shows the cash you need at the register, since the big bag costs more today.

What if a store doesn't carry an item?

Leave its cells empty. The item stays out of the store totals so you compare every store on the same list, and the tool shows the cheapest place for it among the stores that have it.

Do the prices I type get saved or sent anywhere?

No. The math runs in your browser, and nothing you type leaves the page. Print the comparison to keep it.

Read next

Guides that go deeper

Keep planning

Related tools

Checked and dated

Sources

See every source on the site on the sources page. Spotted an error? Tell us.

Photos: Denise Johnson / Unsplash, Rens D / Unsplash, Randy Fath / Unsplash and 3 more, see photo credits